【ASH 2012】儿童ALL诱导治疗时可省略柔红霉素
发布时间:2012-12-10   |   来源:医脉通
关键词: ASH 2012 急性淋巴母细胞白血病 ALL 柔红霉素 心肌病
       2012年12月8日在亚特兰大佐治亚州召开的54届美国血液学年会年会上公布的一项法国最新研究证实,儿童急性淋巴母细胞白血病(ALL)诱导治疗时可以省略对心脏有毒性的蒽环类抗生素柔红霉素

       【研究者说】

       研究主笔——法国巴黎Robert Debré大学医院小儿血液科主任Andre Baruchel博士谈到虽然这在美国已是标准做法,可这种做法赖以确立的研究并没有确切说明柔红霉素在诱导治疗中的作用,而该研究却正好说明了这一点,很多国家仍在诱导治疗中使用柔红霉素,但是否真正必要并不清楚。

       Baruchel博士在阶段III Fralle 2000研究介绍前一天的美国血液学会年会新闻发布会上作了这番表示: “我们的试验表明,它是可有可无的。”

       【同道评论】

       这是一项“非常重要的研究,” ASH主席、加拿大安大略省多伦多大学内科学教授、血液系主任Armaud Keating博士评论道。

       ALL是恶性血流病治疗的成功故事之一,治愈率达85%至90%。然而,尽管这些儿童治好了白血病,不幸的是,有些儿童会在后期出现治疗并发症。后遗症之一便是心脏毒性蒽环类抗生素使用引起的心肌病

       Keating博士补充道“我们谈的是少数病人,但尽管如此,对受害者来说,这种并发症是毁灭性的,其中一些患者最终出现心力衰竭,甚至可能要进行心脏移植。”

       在这项研究中,患者随机分配接受柔红霉素或无柔红霉素诱导化疗,结果显示,不管有无柔红霉素,治疗结果均相似。

       尽管治疗较为彻底,但这些患者仍将需要进行更多的化疗,包括使用另一种蒽环类抗生素多柔比星。研究表明,事先就可以在诱导治疗中省去该药。在诱导治疗中略去柔红霉素的儿童,其心脏病并发症如期减少,这一点是很重要。

       【研究介绍】

       >>复杂的治疗方案

       Fralle 2000研究在法国20家中心和比利时1家中心进行,参与儿童(1-10岁)为标危型B-细胞ALL患者。所有参试患者在开始时都接受了标准的长春新碱地塞米松和天冬酰胺酶联合治疗,21天时通过骨髓样本对治疗效果进行评估,95%左右患者反应良好,1128名反应良好儿童继续随机分配接受柔红霉素或无柔红霉素治疗。(第22、29天时使用柔红霉素,剂量40 mg/m2)。

       剩下的5%患者初始治疗无效,未进行随机分配,全部继续进行柔红霉素治疗。这些患者被判为高危患者,治疗时,“我们不想有任何意外发生,” Barchel博士解释说。

       随机试验后,所有患者继续进行后续系列治疗,包括长春新碱、地塞米松、巯嘌呤和口服甲氨喋呤等巩固治疗。接着是首次75 mg/mm 2多柔比星延迟强化治疗,然后是长春新碱、地塞米松、6-巯嘌呤和甲氨蝶呤的间期治疗,最后是二次长春新碱、甲氨喋呤和天冬酰胺酶延迟强化治疗。所有患者继续维护治疗24个月,其中包括第1年的12剂长春新碱和地塞米松治疗。

       >>相似的结果

       改研究的结果表明,治疗结果是相似的,不管患者是否接受柔红霉素治疗。

       柔红霉素组5年无病生存率(EFS)92.9%,无柔红霉素组患者93.3%;5年总生存率分别为97.2%和98.2%。此外,两组完全缓解率或最小残留疾病没有差异。

       Baruchel博士总结道:“对长春新碱、地塞米松和天冬酰胺酶反应良好的标危型B-细胞系统ALL患者来说,诱导治疗时柔红霉素可有可无。我们现有的有力证据表明,这些儿童在ALL患者中占多数,减少他们的初始化疗数量不会对其产生直接的负面影响, 也许更重要的是,我们知道并预料,取消有害的化疗有助于最大限度地降低他们的后期心脏损坏风险。“

       Baruchel博士透露无相关经济关系。

       美国血液学会年会:摘要第135号


更多阅读
Daunorubicin or Not During the Induction Treatment of Childhood Standard-Risk B-Cell Precursor Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia (SR-BCP-ALL): The Randomized Fralle 2000-A Protocol
 
       From December 2000 to June 2010, 1201 children with SR-BCP-ALL (age: 1-9 years, WBC<50 G/L, CNS-, noMLL rearrangement, no BCR-ABL, no Down syndrome) were included in the FRALLE 2000-A multicenter protocol. At a MFU of 60 months, 1195 patients are evaluable. An ETV6-RUNX1 fusion transcript was documented in 28% of the pts (329 out of 1173 evaluable pts). Induction regimen: prednisone prephase +IT MTX, dexamethasone (DEX) 6 mg/m2/d, vincristine (VCR), native E.coli L-asparaginase ASPA: 6000 IU/m2x 9 infusions). Response was assessed at D8 (blood, good if < 1000 blasts/mm3), D21 (bone marrow morphology, good if less than 5% blasts, so-called M1) and end of induction D35 (bone marrow morphology and DNA-based PCR for Ig/TCR rearrangements MRD). A D21 M1 marrow was observed in 1132 pts (94.7%). Out of these, 1128 pts were randomized to receive daunorubicin (DNR; 40 mg/m2 at D22 and D29) [560 DNR(+) pts] or not [568 DNR(-) pts]. Pts with D21 M2/M3 marrow (n= 61; 5%) were not randomized and received two infusions of DNR. Two pts died before D21. Pts with D21 M1 marrow (A1 group) received after induction a 12 week-consolidation based on VCR, DEX, mercaptopurine (6-MP) and oral methotrexate (MTX), followed by a 1st delayed intensification (reduced “Protocol II”, including a total of 75 mg/m2 of doxorubicin), an interphase therapy (VCR, DEX, 6-MP, MTX), and a triple drug only-2nd delayed intensification (DI°2) (VCR, MTX 100 mg/m2, ASPA 20000 IU/m2; 4 cycles). A 24-month maintenance was then applied, including 12 VCR-DEX pulses the first year. A total of 18 intrathecal injections of MTX was given. Only the rare patients with D21 M3 marrow and/or EOI MRD level ≥1% (n= 47, 4%)(A3 group) received an intensified treatment after CR with 3 block-consolidation, intensified interphase with 6 cycles of MTX 5 g/m2  and a second DI (“reduced protocol II”). No pt received CNS irradiation.
 
       Results:
 
       1. Overall efficacy:  no leukemic induction failure was observed; 4 induction deaths (0.3%) occurred leading to a 99.7% CR rate. Only 30 out 1097 evaluable pts (2.7%) had a decisional EOI MRD ≥ 1%. Eighty-two relapses have been observed (BM: 47, CNS+: 24, BM+CNS: 9, testis: 2). For the whole population 5-year EFS is 91.5% (95%CI: 89.8-93.3), 5-year OS is 97.4% (95%CI: 96.4-98.4). 5-yr EFS and OS for the A1 and A3 groups are 93.1% vs. 61.2% (p<0.0001), and 98.3% vs. 84.2% respectively (p<0.0001). Five-year DFS of the 30 pts with MRD ≥1% is 58.8% (95%CI: 41.7-82.8). Five-year EFS of the children with ETV6-RUNX1 fusion transcript is 96.6% (95%CI: 94.4-98.8).
 
       2. Overall toxicity: 5 non leukemic deaths have been observed after CR (0.4%). Other main toxicities were attributable to ASPA (CNS thrombosis: 1.5%, grade 3-4 pancreatitis: 0.8%, allergic reaction-all grades- during DI °2: 70%). Six cases of secondary neoplasms were observed (AML: 5 pts, astrocytoma: 1 pt).
 
       3. Randomization: 5y EFS and OS from randomization was 92.9% and 97.2% for D21 M1 pts DNR(+) versus 93.3% and 98.2% for D21 M1 DNR(-) pts (p= 0.89 and p= 0.85, respectively). Interestingly EOI MRD levels in the two arms were not different at the sensitivity cut-off of 10-2 (p=0.93) or 10-3(p= 0.74).
 
       4. Prognostic factors: for the whole population, age < 6 years, WBC < 20.000/mm3, ETV6-RUNX1 positivity, as well as D21 marrow M1 and EOI MRD levels of 10-2 and 10-3 were all associated to EFS in univariate analysis. In multivariate analysis remain only WBC < 20.000/mm3 (p=.001), ETV6-RUNX1 positivity (p=.02), EOI MRD levels ≤ 10-3 (p=1.4x10-5). Considering only randomized pts (D21M1 pts) age <6 (p=.004), WBC < 20.000/mm3 (p=.04), ETV6-RUNX1 positivity (p=.01), EOI MRD levels ≤ 10-3(p=.002) remain as independent prognostic factors in multivariate analysis.
 
       Conclusions:
 
       Very good results were obtained with this VCR-DEX-ASPA oriented protocol. SR-BCP ALL pts which represents around 55 % of all children with ALL can be cured with a modest dose of anthracyclin (75 mg/m2). A further decrease in therapy based on the identified prognostic factors could be proposed. Intensification of the chemotherapy for the rare SR pts with a very high MRD has salvaged half of these pts but the addition of new drugs and/or HSCT is now to be evaluated.
Disclosures: No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.
 
(本网站所有内容,凡注明来源为"医脉通",版权均归医脉通所有,未经授权,任何媒体、网站或个人不得转载,否则将追究法律责任,授权转载时须注明"来源:医脉通"。本网注明来源为其他媒体的内容为转载,转载仅作观点分享,版权归原作者所有,如有侵犯版权,请及时联系我们。)
0
收藏
添加表情
全部评论
我要投稿
发表评论
扫码分享

微信扫码分享

回到顶部